Ethical Perceptions of Business Students:
Differences Between East Asia and the USA and Among ‘‘Confucian’’ Cultures
Journal of Business Ethics~ Kun Young Chung
~ John W. Eichenseher
~ Teruso Taniguchi
Confucius remains one of the largest contributiors to Asian culture and philosophy. Confucius lived more than 500 years before the birth of Christ, yet the teachings of Master Kung continue to lie at the heart of the moral philosophies and the ethical decision making of Japan, China, Korea, and many other countries of the Pacific rim. At the heart of this 2200 year old philosophy are core values such as "filial piety," duty, and collectivism. At times, these values contrast with the Western values of individualism, liberty, equality, and individual rights. The researchers of this study set out to find differences and similarities between the business ethics perceptions of university students from the US, China, Japan, and Korea. The study aimed to find differences between Western and Eastern business ethics, yet the results also found vast differences between the ethical perceptions of the three Asian countries as well.

Sampling 842 business students from the US, China, Japan, and Korea, a questionnaire of 76 questions was administered to the students. The responses to all 76 questions were based on a nine-point Likert scale, with one end of the scale as "completely disagree" and the other as "completely agree."
The first part consisted of 32 questions on four business scenarios. An example of one of the scenarios presented was:
Scenario One: An automobile salesman,
warned by the customer that the vehicle
being traded in has a serious engine problem,
does not pass this information on to the indi-
vidual responsible for appraising trade-in
values for the dealership, leading to a poten-
tial over-appraisal of the traded-in value.
The remaining 44 questions were opinion questions on business practices and interpersonal relationships.
The results were as follows:
The most significant differences in average responses were with questions 1 and 4, with regard to the existence of an ethical problem. This is assumed because the questions involve an element of safety, as they deal with the sale of cars.
Interesting significant differences in perceptions were: US students recognizing ethical problems and choosing not to follow the same practice, and Asian participants tended to regard productivity and corporate communication as having greater importance than social responsibility or ethical decision making.
As economic ties between the US and Asia continue to strengthen, especially with the continued expansion of the Chinese economy, the consideration of business interaction and ethical decisions should be a substantial concern. The implication of differing ethical codes is that expectations during times of business negotiations and dealings may differ between American and Asian parties.
Sources:
Kun Chung, John Eichenseher, and Teruso Taniguchi. "
Ethical Perceptions of Business Students:
Differences Between East Asia and the USA and Among ‘‘Confucian’’ Cultures." Journal of Business Ethics. 2008, vol. 79, issue 1, pp. 121-132.